Founding cohort open: 50 spots Get your free grade
SellerCritic
The context layer for your online store

Generic advice is worthless. We learn your business first.

It starts with a brutally honest grade. Then SellerCritic keeps the context of your margins, buyer, positioning and voice, so every fix, rewrite and idea after that is built for your store, not a template.

https://
WORKS WITH ETSY & SHOPIFY  ·  NO LOGIN  ·  FIRST GRADE FREE AT LAUNCH
Report card · sample
yarnandthread.etsy.com
0
OUT OF 100
C+Above average
Solid bones, sloppy execution. Two fixes make this a B+.
PHOTOS Muddy lighting on 4 of 12. Reshoot on white. D
SEO Titles chase tags nobody searches for. C
PRICE 40% underpriced. Reviews justify more. C
COPY Buries the key detail in line six. B
Your hero photo has seven props and no productYou wrote a poem where a title should beFourteen dollars for handmade reads as a red flagNobody is searching for boho artisan vibes
Private beta
Opening in weeks
50
Founding spots
$99/yr
Locked for life
30s
To first grade

The grade is the hook. The context is the product.

The context layer

Every other tool hands you the same best-practice checklist. SellerCritic learns your business once, then holds onto it. The same critique reads completely differently when it knows your numbers.

Generic advice

"Consider raising your prices to improve your margins."

Knows nothing. True for everyone, useful to no one.
With your context

"You're the deliberate budget pick, so don't touch price. Your $11 cost is the problem. Switch to the bulk vessel supplier and your margin jumps to 61%."

Knows your positioning, cost and goal. Advice only you could get.
01
Your economics
Margins, costs and order volume behind every sale.
02
Your buyer
Who you're actually selling to, and why they buy.
03
Your positioning
Budget, mid or premium, so advice fits your strategy.
04
Your voice
So every rewrite sounds like your brand, not AI.

The grade covers four things. Your context sharpens all four.

Graded criteria
01
Photography
Lighting, framing, first-image impact and catalog consistency.
02
SEO & tags
Titles and tags scored against real search volume, then rewritten term by term.
03
Pricing
Where you sit against your category and the margin you're leaving behind.
04
Copy & listings
Descriptions, variations and policies that quietly kill conversions.
Sample review
D
CATEGORY
Photography
an example we see weekly

"Your hero photo has seven props and no product. Buyers can't tell what they're actually buying, so they scroll. Cut six of them and shoot the candle on plain white."

THE FIX One reshoot, one afternoon, measurable difference.
The method

From graded to fixed, in the time it takes to make coffee.

1
Paste your URL

Drop your shop link. No login, no card, no plugin to install.

2
Read the review

A grade per listing, benchmarked against shops that actually convert in your niche.

3
Fix what matters

Work a to-do list ranked by revenue, not busywork. Re-grade anytime.

Rates

First grade free at launch
Free grade
$0

One full shop grade with your top three fixes, free when the beta opens. Join the list to claim yours.

Overall score + letter grade Top 3 priority fixes
Grade my shop, free
Founding member
50 SPOTS
$99/yr

Everything in Pro ($19/mo at launch), at less than half price, locked for life. Charged today, full refund if we don't ship your access.

Every listing scored Revenue-ranked fix list Rewritten titles & tags First access, founder's direct line
Claim a founding spot
Studio
$49/mo

For sellers running multiple shops or managing clients. Opens after the founding cohort.

Up to 10 shops Side-by-side comparisons White-label reports
Talk to us

Find out what your shop really scores.

Thirty seconds to get in line, free. The truth might sting. Your revenue will thank you.

Grade my shop
© 2026 SellerCritic · a Momentum company Not affiliated with Etsy or Shopify.